key person insurance who can a company insure

Florida Key Man Insurance: Who a Company Can Insure

Your company’s top engineer just left, or a co-owner has died, and now someone asks whether the business could have insured them. Here’s the short answer: a company can generally insure a person when it would lose real money if that person died. This is called insurable interest, and it sets the limits on who a company can insure with key man insurance. Florida law also requires the insured person’s written consent before the policy is bought.

What Insurable Interest Means in Key Person Life Insurance

Insurable interest means the policy owner stands to lose money if the insured person dies. Key man insurance, also called key person life insurance, is usually a policy the company owns. The company pays the premiums and receives the death benefit. That setup works only when the company has a real financial stake in the person’s life.

Florida’s insurance law puts the rule in plain terms. No one may buy insurance on another person’s life unless the benefits are payable to that person, or to someone who had an insurable interest when the contract was made, under Fla. Stat. § 627.404. An insurable interest exists when someone expects a substantial financial advantage from another person’s continued life, or when someone is closely related by blood or by law to that person and has a substantial interest engendered by love and affection.

The timing matters. The test applies when the contract is made. The statute says the insurable interest need not exist after coverage starts. So the question is whether the company had a financial stake at the start.

Here’s a simple way to see it. A company that depends on one designer’s client relationships would lose real money if that designer died. A company with no such dependence would not.

Who a Company Can Insure: Key Employees, Executives and Owners

A company can usually insure its owners, directors, officers, partners, managers and key employees or key persons. Florida law gives a business entity that interest, as long as it gets the person’s written consent first. The same statute covers the business’s affiliates and subsidiaries.

The statute ties “key employee” and “key person” to a federal tax code section that describes certain positions or pay levels. In practice, the people most often considered key include:

  • Founders and senior executives who set the direction of the business.
  • Employees with hard-to-replace knowledge or relationships, if their position or compensation is described in s. 101(j)(2)(A)(ii) of the Internal Revenue Code and they give written consent before the insurance is purchased.
  • Owners and shareholders, because their death can change the company’s value and continuity.

A job title alone does not make someone key. The real question is whether the person’s position or compensation is described in s. 101(j)(2)(A)(ii) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986. Two people with the same title can carry very different weight.

Showing a Real Financial Loss Tied to the Insured Person

The company needs a real, measurable loss that comes from the person’s role. A general worry that the business would suffer is not enough. Good records connect the person to the money.

Useful records often include:

  • The person’s job duties and reporting lines.
  • Revenue, profit margin or client accounts the person drives.
  • Loans, leases or contracts that depend on the person.
  • The likely cost and time needed to recruit and train a replacement.

These figures shape how much coverage the company considers. A business that estimates a large loss may consider more coverage. One with a smaller estimate may consider less.

Accuracy matters. An insurer may rely on what the applicant says about insurable interest. It is not liable for untrue statements it relies on in good faith, under Fla. Stat. § 627.404, except as set forth in the policy. The company’s records should back up what its application says.

Co-Owners, Partners and Buy-Sell Agreements

Co-owners can hold coverage on one another so the surviving owners can fund the purchase of a deceased owner’s share. This is different from key person coverage. Key person insurance protects operations and cash flow after a loss. Buy-sell insurance funds the transfer of an ownership share. The two can work together, but they answer different questions.

Consider three co-owners who each carry a policy on the others. If one dies, the survivors may use the proceeds to buy that owner’s share under the agreement. The agreement sets the price and the steps. The insurance only supplies the cash.

Florida partnership law has its own default rule. If a partner leaves without dissolving the partnership, the partnership must buy that partner’s interest at a price set by statute, under Fla. Stat. § 620.8701; however, a partner who wrongfully dissociates before the expiration of a definite term or the completion of a particular undertaking is not entitled to payment of any portion of the buyout price until the expiration of the term or completion of the undertaking, unless the court finds earlier payment will not cause undue hardship. Owners should learn that rule before a loss, not after.

For how buy-sell agreements are structured and funded, see our buy-sell agreement insurance guide.

Consent, Ownership and Timing Rules

Florida law generally requires the insured person, having legal capacity to contract, to apply for or consent in writing to the contract and its terms on or before the time the contract is made, though prepaid funeral contracts, group life insurance, and group or blanket accident, health, or disability insurance are excluded. Florida law requires that written consent for a key employee or key person.

Some group and prepaid funeral contracts are excluded.

Federal reporting follows too. The return shows the number of employees of the business at year end, the number of insured employees, the total insurance in force, the business’s name, address, and taxpayer identification number, its type of business, and whether valid consent exists for each insured employee, under IRC § 6039I. The business must also keep records, so consent forms belong in the file.

Ownership and beneficiary setup matter when the policy is issued. Key person policies are usually owned by the company and paid to the company. The insurer’s underwriting applies to the insured person, including any health questions. The insurer decides whether and on what terms to issue the policy.

A later job change or ownership change can raise new questions. Review those changes early.

Where the Answer Depends on the Facts

The answer depends on the facts. Several common situations are less clear than they look.

  • A former employee. Whether the business can insure a former employee turns on whether it has an insurable interest when the contract is made.
  • Co-owners with uneven stakes. A larger owner may face a different loss than a smaller one.
  • A key person who lives or works outside the United States. Location can raise separate questions.
  • A company changing hands. A sale, merger or restructuring can change who has the stake.

State law and the policy wording also apply. Those details should be checked against the company’s own records before any decision.

The firm is a CPA practice in Miami that helps families and business owners choose and buy life insurance. Nischay Rawal is a licensed insurance agent in Florida. Insurance is offered through the licensed agent, separately from the accounting practice. Florida law requires agents to clearly say they act as insurance agents and to identify the insurers involved, under Fla. Stat. § 626.9531. Any fee for a coverage review is disclosed in writing before work begins.

Next Steps and Related Questions

After insurable interest is settled, the next questions cover policy type, funding and how proceeds are used. Our key person insurance guide covers those topics in more depth.

Policy type matters. FINRA explains that term life insurance has a limited coverage period. Whole or permanent life insurance covers the insured’s lifetime and includes a cash-value feature, under FINRA’s insurance overview.

Does a company need the employee’s written consent?

Yes. Florida law requires written consent from a key employee or key person before the business buys insurance on that person.

Are key man insurance proceeds taxed?

For employer-owned policies, such as many key person policies, IRC § 101(j)(1) generally limits the tax-free portion of the death benefit to the sum of the premiums and other amounts paid by the policyholder for the contract, unless an exception in IRC § 101(j)(2) applies. Those exceptions include amounts paid to a member of the insured’s family, to a designated beneficiary other than the policyholder, to a trust for their benefit, or to the insured’s estate, and certain cases involving an insured who was an employee or director when the policy was issued, where written notice and consent were given. Whether an exception applies depends on how the policy is owned and structured. A transfer of the policy for value can limit that exclusion, under 26 U.S.C. § 101.

Can a business insure a former employee?

It depends on whether the business has an insurable interest when the contract is made. Current job duties and the company’s financial stake both matter.

If a partner’s illness or a key employee’s departure has you asking who your company can insure, you don’t have to work through it alone. Reach out to our team to arrange a coverage review.

NR CPAs & Business Advisors, LLC, 782 NW 42nd Avenue, Suite 534, Miami, FL 33126. Life insurance is offered by Nischay Rawal, a Florida-licensed life and health insurance agent (license G066337). This page is general information about life insurance, not tax, legal or investment advice, and not an offer of any specific policy. Coverage, premiums and benefits depend on the issuing insurer's underwriting and the policy's terms. Policy loans and withdrawals reduce cash value and the death benefit and may have tax consequences.
Call Now (305) 872-3096