Indiana's Tax Surge: Reviving the Spirit of Bootlegging
Indiana's latest cigarette tax hike channels the bootlegging era, not just reforming fiscal policy but reviving a heritage of clandestine commerce. As the state raises its per-pack price, lawmakers are instituting rigorous penalties reminiscent of Prohibition-era raids on moonshiners, targeting smuggling networks that recall historic crackdowns.
The nostalgia is palpable, echoing the mid‑1930s' efforts to dismantle illicit beer and tobacco networks. Today, however, the strategy has shifted focus from hidden stills to multi-state highways, where consumers evade taxes by venturing across borders to access lower-priced products.
States like Kentucky and Tennessee provide cautionary examples. Kentucky’s very low cigarette tax—a mere 10 cents per pack versus Indiana’s $1—makes it a prime hotspot for smuggling, with cigarette smuggling routes stretching far beyond its borders. Tennessee similarly witnessed a rise in illegal cigarette dens post-tax hikes mirrored after so-called "beer flats."
Yet, the scenario offers deeper insights. A 2018 analysis by Johns Hopkins shows that states like Indiana could enjoy significant revenue boosts despite elevated taxes. After Indiana's 2007 tax increase from 55¢ to 99.5¢ per pack, its revenue jumped a striking 43% within a year, even as adjoining states recorded moderate decreases.
Comprehensive Enforcement: Indiana's Legal Overhaul
From July 1, Indiana's cigarette tax nearly triples, paired with robust enforcement measures:
Outlawing large-scale out-of-state purchases, converting bulk operations into felonious offenses.
Strengthening task forces—such as Excise and state police—to oversee shipments, focusing on toll booths and storage facilities.
Surprise audits of wholesalers and retailers to seize counterfeit tax stamps.
Anticipated revenue impact: $290 million annually, directed for public health initiatives.
Cross-Border Challenges & Systemic Gaps
However, enforcement remains critical. Indiana's closeness to low-tax regions like Kentucky predisposes it to illicit trade. The Tax Foundation's report identifies Indiana among states with heightened smuggling risks post-tax increases, warning of pervasive gray markets and border-purchasing activities.
Ohio, with its relatively modest cigarette tax and expansive highway network, also poses a concern. The 2024 Mackinac Center study projects nearly 12% of cigarettes consumed in Indiana will originate from external purchases following the tax change.
Case Studies: Illinois & New York Strategies
Illinois:
Illinois elevated taxes on nicotine products to 45% of wholesale, amplifying smuggling risks.
Approximately 30% of cigarettes are reportedly smuggled across state lines.
The state enforces steep fines against unstamped packs—$20–$25 per package—and intensified restrictions on high-volume shipments post-2019 tax elevation.
New York:
With some of the country's steepest taxes, New York has witnessed over 50% smuggling rates, temporarily topping at 61% after a recent $1-per-pack increase.
The Albany-based Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco & Firearms and the state's Tax Enforcement Office adopt felony-level trafficking laws (D/E felonies for 10,000+ cigarettes).
The Legacy of Indiana’s Economic Ingenuity
Bootlegging is ingrained in Indiana's financial narrative. During Prohibition, Indiana hosted prominent moonshine operations, especially in the rural southern counties of Lawrence, Dubois, and Orange. These operations utilized "Whiskey Roads" for transportation under the veil of night.
While the medium has evolved—packs versus pints—the methodology remains remarkably akin: identifying legal loopholes, exploiting geographic advantages, and executing undetectable product movement.
Even veteran Indiana Excise officer John Halverson noted the similarities: “In the past, it was barn-based stills. Today, it’s cigarette cartons concealed in car trunks.”
Is This a Public Health Triumph or a Policy Risk?
Considerable debate surrounds the smuggling uptick. Public health proponents suggest that, despite evasive buying, increased prices significantly lower smoking rates, particularly among teenagers and low-income individuals.
Mike Seilback, National Assistant Vice President for Advocacy at the American Lung Association, shared with The Indiana Capital Chronicle: "Raising tobacco prices is the most effective means to deter smoking, period. We anticipate countless Hoosiers will resign their smoking habit, while countless adolescents may never adopt it."
Despite potential smuggling up to 10–30%, data indicates states can continue to glean substantial net revenue gains post-tax increase if enforcement remains vigorous. Indiana's 2007 case—a 41% dip in sales contrasting a 43% revenue lift—demonstrates this potential.
Assessing Indiana's Strategy: A Question of Balance
Indiana has staked heavily on this initiative. But success relies on factors beyond fiscal projections. Will the state balance deterrence with enforcement? Can small-town businesses adjust successfully? Will the modern-day bootleggers—sleek "moonshine" transporters in SUVs and rented trucks—find new ways to stay ahead?
Time will reveal the answers. But presently, the iconic spirit of the 1930s is rekindling on the Midwest's less-traveled roads. With heightened stakes, speedier transportation, and more sophisticated counterfeit protection, the endeavor remains quintessentially Indiana.
Want tax & accounting tips and insights?
Sign up for our newsletter.